Hotels near Shell Beach Shelter Island

Free cancellation options if plans change
Unlock travel rewards with One Key
Save more with Member Prices

Check prices for these dates

Tonight
Apr 30 - May 1
Tomorrow
May 1 - May 2
This weekend
May 2 - May 4
Next weekend
May 9 - May 11

Where to stay near Shell Beach?

The Menhaden
Property entrance

The Menhaden

3.5 star property
9.6 out of 10, Exceptional, (149)
The price is $437
includes taxes & fees
$387 per night
May 1 - May 2
The Menhaden
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.

Other landmarks in Shelter Island

Saw some fishing nets set up as I was driving along Noyac Beach road towards Sag Harbor Long Island. Had to stop and get a long exposure shot.

Foster Memorial Town Beach

Why not spend a carefree afternoon at Foster Memorial Town Beach during your travels in Noyack? Wander the waterfront and parks while you're in the area.

See properties in Foster Memorial Town Beach
Foster Memorial Town Beach
A tranquil hotel pool encircled by beautiful arches, enhancing the ambiance for leisure and relaxation.

Summer Getaway Sale

Save 25% or more on select hotels, and earn 50% more rewards on all properties. Book by May 26 and travel by Sep 30, 2025. See terms*
Sign in or join for free

Frequently asked questions

What are the best hotels near Shell Beach?
  • Guests love staying at The Rams Head Inn, which is an inn near Shell Beach.
  • Also highly rated is West Neck Guesthouse, which is 7 minutes away by car.
  • In fact, you’ll have plenty of options to choose from with 5,781 hotels, vacation rentals, and other accommodation options in the area.
How much does it cost to stay in a hotel near Shell Beach?
On Hotels.com, you can find the best options for your travel budget by entering your search criteria and sorting by price. Remember that pricing varies based on where and when you plan to go.
  • Search for the lowest price per night $161
What cheap hotels are close to Shell Beach?
  • Shelter Island House is a reasonably-priced hotel near Shell Beach and offers a free continental breakfast, free parking, and free in-room WiFi.
  • Another low-cost alternative is Sunset Beach, which is 7 minutes away by car.
Can I find hotels close to Shell Beach that are fully refundable?
Yes, there are many hotels with refundable room rates, but be sure to check the cancellation deadline. Find refundable rates using the “Fully refundable” filter when you search for hotels.
What are the best romantic hotels near Shell Beach?
  • For travelers looking for a romantic stay, The Rams Head Inn offers a beach, 2 restaurants, and couples/private dining. It’s a short 16-minute drive from Shell Beach.
  • The Shoals Suites and Slips is another great choice, and it’s 35 minutes away by car.
What are the best hotels close to Shell Beach with free breakfast?
  • Start your day nourished with a free continental breakfast at Shelter Island House, which is a short 7-minute drive from Shell Beach.
  • West Neck Guesthouse is also a recommended place to stay with a free continental breakfast. It’s 7 minutes away by car.
Which hotels near Shell Beach have rooms with great views?
What are the best family hotels close to Shell Beach?
  • The entire family will enjoy a stay at The Pridwin Hotel which offers children’s meals, a private beach, and a seasonal outdoor pool. Shell Beach is 7 minutes away by car.
  • Another great option for your family’s trip is Shelter Island House.
What are the best luxury hotels near Shell Beach?
  • Pamper yourself with a stay at Topping Rose House, which is a 34-minute drive from Shell Beach. This hotel features a restaurant called Topping Rose and has an outdoor pool and a full-service spa.
  • Another luxe option is Mill House Inn, which is 39 minutes away by car.
What are the best hotels near Shell Beach with free parking?
  • Drive and park with ease when you stay at West Neck Guesthouse, which offers free parking. You’ll be a short 7-minute drive from Shell Beach.
  • House on Chase Creek also has free parking and is 9 minutes away by car.
What are the best hotels near Shell Beach with a pool?
  • Travelers can enjoy the seasonal outdoor pool at The Pridwin Hotel. Shell Beach is a short 7-minute drive from the hotel.
  • Another great choice for a hotel with a pool is Baron’s Cove.
What cheap motels can I book close to Shell Beach?
  • To save on your stay near Shell Beach, take a look at The Hampton Maid, which offers a seasonal outdoor pool and a restaurant.
  • A Room At The Beach is another inexpensive motel to consider in the area.
What are the best things to see and do around my hotel near Shell Beach?
  • You can spend the day relaxing by the water at Shell Beach, though you might also want to see nearby sights like Mystic Seaport, Mystic Aquarium and Institute for Exploration, and Ocean Beach Park.
  • New London Ferry Dock, Cooper’s Beach, and Splish Splash Water Park are other places to visit in the area.
What are the best lodges close to Shell Beach?
What are the best cabins close to Shell Beach?
What are the best campsites near Shell Beach?
  • Safari Tent Glamping,S6-CedarPt, East Hampton, NY: Experience tranquility when you stay within reach of Shell Beach. This campsite offers guests a beach.
  • Safari Tent Glamping,D28-CedarPt, East Hampton, NY: This is another option in the larger area where you can enjoy nature.
What are the best pet-friendly hotels close to Shell Beach?

Terms and conditions

*Book by 5/26/2025 11:59 pm in hotel property local time. Stay between 4/17/2025-9/30/2025. Member Prices are available to Hotels.com® app users and One Key members. Limited availability, blackout periods may apply.

OneKeyCash is not redeemable for cash and can only be used on Hotels.com®, Expedia®, and Vrbo®.

https://www.hotels.com/lp/b/deals