Hotels in Fire Island Pines

Seaside Serenity: Unveiling the Allure of Fire Island Pines

Nestled along the stunning coastline of Fire Island, Fire Island Pines is a vibrant haven renowned for its pristine beaches and welcoming community. This LGBTQ+ friendly destination boasts picturesque landscapes, charming boardwalks, and a lively marina, perfect for sunbathing, swimming, and socializing. Explore the serene picnic areas or take a leisurely stroll to the iconic Fire Island Lighthouse. With its blend of natural beauty and vibrant culture, Fire Island Pines offers an idyllic escape for those seeking relaxation, romance, and a dash of adventure amid the tranquil sea and sandy shores. For our best hotel rates in Fire Island Pines and to enhance your stay, be sure to check out Hotels.com's Last-Minute DealsOpens in a new window on travel.

Discover great hotels in Fire Island Pines

Fire Island Pines offers a variety of accommodations, from cozy guest houses to charming boutique hotels. Many properties feature private bathrooms and free Wi-Fi, ensuring a comfortable stay. Whether you’re seeking a laid-back retreat or an upscale getaway, you'll find inviting options to suit your needs. Here are some of the most popular hotels with our travelers in Fire Island Pines:

1. Come As You Are InnOpens in a new window: Come As You Are Inn is a charming 3.5-star Bed and Breakfast located just steps from the beach, perfect for travelers seeking a relaxing beach vacation experience. The inn boasts comfortable accommodations, a delightful homemade breakfast crafted by the chef, and a lovely backyard with a pool. The warm and engaging hosts create a welcoming atmosphere that leaves a lasting impression, ensuring a memorable stay filled with personal touches and exceptional service. Guests rave about the attention to detail and the delightful breakfast options, making this inn a favored choice for those looking for a unique and personalized getaway.
2. Jake's 58 Casino Hotel - Adult OnlyOpens in a new window: Jake's 58 Casino Hotel - Adult Only is a stylish 3.5-star hotel that offers a vibrant atmosphere for leisure travelers. With clean, spacious rooms and a lively bistro, this hotel provides a comfortable retreat. Guests appreciate the seamless check-in process and the security features that enhance their experience. The hotel features a cafe in the lobby with freshly made beverages, perfect for a quick pick-me-up. The spacious accommodations and attentive housekeeping create an enjoyable environment, making it a great choice for those seeking a relaxing and enjoyable stay.
3. The Palms Hotel Fire IslandOpens in a new window: The Palms Hotel Fire Island is a welcoming 3.5-star hotel designed for pet owners looking for a relaxing getaway. This property allows pets and provides a friendly atmosphere where travelers can feel at home. The staff delivers exceptional service, ensuring that every guest's needs are met. The accommodations are designed for comfort, allowing guests to unwind and enjoy their stay. The hotel’s pet-friendly policy and warm hospitality make it an ideal choice for travelers who wish to bring their furry companions along for a memorable escape.

Top locations to stay in Fire Island Pines

When visiting Fire Island Pines, great areas to stay include North Bellport, Ronkonkoma, and West Bay Shore. Ronkonkoma is appealing for its gardens and nearby attractions like Lake Ronkonkoma and Sunken Meadow State Park. North Bellport offers a serene island vibe, while West Bay Shore boasts beautiful waterfront views. For first-time visitors, Ronkonkoma provides the best blend of activities and accessibility.

1. RonkonkomaOpens in a new window: Ronkonkoma is a charming community with beautiful gardens and scenic views, making it a delightful place to stay. Just a short distance from Fire Island Pines, you can explore the tranquil Lake Ronkonkoma, perfect for a relaxing day by the water. Outdoor enthusiasts will love Sunken Meadow State Park, which offers stunning walking trails and picnic spots. For some fun, check out the local cultural scene at Patchogue Theatre for the Performing Arts, perfect for catching a show. With its small-town vibe, Ronkonkoma provides a peaceful retreat while still being close to vibrant attractions.
2. North BellportOpens in a new window: North Bellport is a hidden gem that embodies the charm of island living. Nestled close to the coast, it offers a laid-back atmosphere ideal for those looking to unwind. The nearby beaches are perfect for sunbathing and enjoying ocean breezes. While the area is quieter, its proximity to Fire Island Pines allows for easy access to both relaxation and vibrant island life. It’s a great choice for travelers seeking a serene environment while still being near exciting destinations.
3. West Bay ShoreOpens in a new window: West Bay Shore is a lovely spot that combines the beauty of waterfront living with a touch of small-town charm. This area is known for its picturesque views and access to local parks, making it great for leisurely strolls or bike rides. You can enjoy scenic waterfront dining options and unique local shops that capture the essence of coastal living. It’s an inviting place to stay, allowing you to soak up the tranquil atmosphere while being a short trip away from the lively activities in Fire Island Pines.

Things to do in Fire Island Pines

Fire Island Pines is a vibrant coastal paradise where stunning beaches meet the sparkling sea. Visitors can enjoy thrilling activities like surfing and boating by day, followed by lively dancing under the stars. With breathtaking sunsets and serene parks, this destination offers a perfect blend of relaxation and excitement for all.

• Ocean BeachOpens in a new window – Dive into the sun and surf at Ocean Beach, where golden sands meet the inviting waves. This lively beach is perfect for sunbathing, swimming, or enjoying a leisurely stroll along the shore. With its vibrant atmosphere, it’s an ideal spot to relax and soak up the island’s charm.
• Sunken ForestOpens in a new window – Explore the enchanting trails of the Sunken Forest, a unique natural wonder. This tranquil woodland is home to diverse plant life and wildlife, providing a serene escape from the beach scene. Wander through the lush greenery and discover the beauty of this hidden gem.
• Cherry Grove Community House and TheatreOpens in a new window – Experience the vibrant arts scene at the Cherry Grove Community House and Theatre. Attend a live performance or community event in this historic venue, where creativity thrives. It’s a wonderful place to connect with locals and enjoy the artistic spirit of Fire Island Pines.
• Carrington HouseOpens in a new window – Step back in time at Carrington House, a landmark that showcases the rich history of the area. This historic residence offers a glimpse into the past and is a must-see for those interested in architecture and local heritage. Take a moment to appreciate its unique design and significance.
• Sayville Bathing BeachOpens in a new window – Unwind at Sayville Bathing Beach, a peaceful spot perfect for swimming and picnicking. The calm waters and family-friendly atmosphere make it an excellent choice for a day of fun in the sun. Pack a lunch and enjoy a relaxing afternoon by the water.

5 tips for savvy savings when booking a hotel in Fire Island Pines

1. Book for the cheapest times: The most budget-friendly time to visit Fire Island Pines is between January and March, when hotel prices are likely to drop. For those on a budget, staying for at least 2 to 3 days is perfect for discovering the area's significant landmarks, rich history, and cultural offerings. During your visit, you can explore the beautiful beaches, the picturesque marina, and the unique charm of the islands. This timeframe not only provides great value for money but also allows travelers to fully appreciate the natural beauty and historical significance of Fire Island Pines.
2. Look for last-minute deals on Hotels.com: To explore last-minute deals to Fire Island Pines, visit the DealsOpens in a new window or Last-Minute DealsOpens in a new window section on Hotels.com, where you may discover discounted rates on accommodations as your travel date approaches. To stay informed about flash sales and special promotions, consider enabling email alerts or push notifications from Hotels.com. Utilizing the Smart ShoppingOpens in a new window tool in the app allows you to compare hotel prices and amenities, increasing your chances of finding the best options. If prices drop or new rooms become available, you could be one of the first to book your spontaneous getaway.
3. Be flexible with dates: Prices can fluctuate based on various factors, including the hotel's location, star rating, and the time of year, so being flexible with your travel dates may help you save on your stay at a Fire Island Pines hotel. If you're seeking something distinctive, boutique hotels often provide a more personalized experience and might offer better value. When you book through Hotels.com, we'll inform you if the price for your chosen dates is above or below the average. If the price is on the higher end, we may recommend more affordable dates, increasing the likelihood that you'll save.
4. Consider your location: Choosing to stay near major attractions or downtown areas can be convenient, but it often comes with a higher price tag. For more budget-friendly options, you might want to look at hotels in less central neighborhoods, where you can find a balance between cost and accessibility to the sites you want to visit. Independent hotels located a bit further out are often more likely to be affordable and can offer a more genuine experience.
5. Join One Key™: Become a One Key MemberOpens in a new window for free and book your next stay in Fire Island Pines. Save on over 100,000 hotels worldwide with exclusive member prices. As a member, you can quickly progress through the tiers and enjoy perks, like free room upgrades when available and food and beverage discounts at select VIP Access properties.

Best time to go to Fire Island Pines

Fire Island Pines experiences its lowest average temperature in January, at 34.5°F (1.4°C), while July is the hottest month, with an average temperature of 75.4°F (24.1°C). December tends to be the wettest month. The peak travel months to visit Fire Island Pines are June to August, which see a higher number of tourists. During this peak period, the weather is mostly sunny, accompanied by light rainfall. In contrast, October to December are ideal if you're looking for a calmer vacation, marked by light rainfall and mostly sunny conditions.